Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Which Cruise Line Is Right for You in 2025?
When it comes to choosing between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, the decision can feel overwhelming.
Both are among the biggest names in the cruise industry, offering exciting itineraries, entertainment, and dining options. But which one is the best fit for your next vacation?
After sailing on both, I’m breaking down the key differences—from pricing and cabins to dining and entertainment—so you can decide which cruise line is best for you.
Prefer to watch instead? I’ve got a full video breakdown on my YouTube channel, where I share even more personal insights and tips! Click here to watch!
Pricing & Value: Which Cruise Line is More Affordable?
Let’s be real—budget is one of the biggest factors when booking a cruise.
Carnival is often the more affordable option, offering lower base fares and frequent deals. They also tend to have fewer extra fees for onboard activities, making it a great choice if you’re looking for a fun trip without breaking the bank.
Royal Caribbean, on the other hand, is usually more expensive, but you’re paying for more high-tech ships, innovative activities (like skydiving simulators and robotic bartenders), and an elevated experience. If you love over-the-top entertainment and don’t mind spending a little extra, Royal Caribbean might be worth the splurge.
Winner: Carnival for budget-conscious travelers, Royal Caribbean for overall value & for those willing to splurge.
Carnival’s Family Harbor Suite
Cabins: Which Cruise Line Offers the Best Rooms?
If cabin space is important to you, Royal Caribbean has the edge. Their ships tend to have larger, more modern cabins, with options like interior virtual balcony rooms and two-story loft suites. The decor feels sleek and upscale, making it a good fit if you love a more luxurious feel.
Carnival’s cabins are often bigger than industry standards, but they have a simpler, more colorful design. While they’re comfortable and spacious, they don’t always have the same modern touch as Royal Caribbean’s. That said, if you’re sailing on one of Carnival’s newer ships (like the Mardi Gras), the cabins are more updated and stylish.
Winner: Royal Caribbean
Ellis digging into some crispy chicken tenders from Shaq’s Big Chicken aboard the Carnival Celebration!.
Dining: Who Has the Best Food?
Food can make or break a cruise experience, and both cruise lines bring their A-game—but in different ways.
Carnival is known for casual, comfort food with a fun twist. Think unlimited Guy’s Burgers, BlueIguana tacos, Shaq’s Big Chicken, and 24-hour pizza. Their dining atmosphere is lively and relaxed, making it perfect for foodies who love indulgent eats without the fuss.
Royal Caribbean, on the other hand, offers a more refined dining experience, with gourmet options like Wonderland (their whimsical, molecular gastronomy restaurant) and Izumi (for sushi lovers). They have more specialty dining options, but you’ll pay extra for most of them. Their included dining options are solid but not as varied as Carnival’s.
Winner: Carnival for casual food lovers, Royal Caribbean for gourmet dining.
Entertainment & Activities: Who Does It Best?
Both cruise lines are known for non-stop fun, but the vibe is very different.
Carnival is all about high-energy fun, with deck parties, comedy shows, and live music around every corner. Their sail-away parties are legendary, and they offer more late-night entertainment, making it great for night owls. If you love a party vibe, Carnival is the way to go.
Royal Caribbean is known for big-production entertainment, including Broadway-style shows, ice skating performances, and high-tech experiences like virtual reality escape rooms. Their ships also have thrill-seeker activities like ziplining, surf simulators, and even skydiving simulators.
If you’re all about high-energy fun, Carnival wins. If you love jaw-dropping performances and high-tech activities, Royal Caribbean takes the prize.
Winner: Tie – Carnival for nightlife and parties, Royal Caribbean for shows and thrills.
Destinations & Itineraries: Which Cruise Line Takes You to the Best Places?
Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer cruises to the Caribbean, Bahamas, Mexico, and beyond.
Carnival specializes in shorter, budget-friendly cruises (3-5 days), making it ideal if you’re looking for a quick getaway. They also sail to some less common ports like Mobile, Alabama, and Baltimore, Maryland.
Royal Caribbean offers more diverse itineraries, including longer, more exotic cruises (think Mediterranean, Asia, and Alaska). If you want to explore beyond the typical Caribbean routes, Royal Caribbean gives you more options.
Winner: Royal Caribbean for variety, Carnival for budget-friendly trips.
My son, Ellis, making a new friend while enjoying Carnival’s Dr. Seuss Lounge & Library
Which Cruise Line is Best for Families with Young Kids?
Traveling with little ones? Both lines cater to families, but in different ways.
Royal Caribbean: Adventure for All Ages
Kid’s Clubs: Adventure Ocean (starting at 6 months old), with interactive activities and science labs.
Pools & Water Fun: Splashaway Bay water park, FlowRider surf simulator, and even indoor skydiving on some ships.
Entertainment: Ice skating shows, high-tech performances, and DreamWorks character meet-and-greets on select ships.
Babysitting: Nursery for babies (extra cost) and late-night group babysitting.
Carnival: Budget-Friendly Family Fun
Kid’s Clubs: Camp Ocean (divided into age groups) and Night Owls babysitting for late nights.
Pools & Water Fun: WaterWorks water parks, splash pads, and mini waterslides for younger kids.
Entertainment: Dr. Seuss at Sea (character parades & interactive storytime), family-friendly comedy, and Build-A-Bear at Sea.
Winner: Royal Caribbean for older kids who love adventure, Carnival for younger kids and budget-conscious families.
Which Cruise Line Has the Best Drink Package?
If you’re someone who loves a good cocktail (or three) while cruising, the drink package can be a game-changer—or a complete waste of money, depending on your drinking habits. Here’s how Royal Caribbean and Carnival compare when it comes to their drink packages.
Royal Caribbean: Deluxe Beverage Package
Pricing: Typically $63–$89 per day, depending on the sailing and promotions.
Includes: Cocktails, beer, wine by the glass, soda, bottled water, specialty coffee (Starbucks on some ships), fresh juices, and mocktails.
Restrictions: Every adult in the same stateroom must purchase the package.
Extras: You get discounts on bottles of wine and access to a variety of premium liquor brands.
Carnival: Cheers! Package
Pricing: $59.95 per day (if purchased in advance) or $64.95 per day onboard.
Includes: Cocktails, beer, wine by the glass (up to $20 per drink), soda, energy drinks, bottled water, specialty coffee, and mocktails.
Restrictions: A hard limit of 15 alcoholic drinks per day (soft drinks and water are unlimited).
Extras: 25% discount on bottles of wine and certain spirits.
Winner: Royal Caribbean for unlimited drinks, Carnival for a better deal if you don’t drink a lot.
The Overall Winner: Which Cruise Line Should You Choose?
The best cruise line depends on what kind of vacation you want!
Pick Carnival if you love a fun, casual atmosphere, budget-friendly pricing, and comfort food. It’s the ultimate “fun ship” experience, great for first-time cruisers and party lovers.
Pick Royal Caribbean if you’re looking for luxury on a budget, high-tech thrills, and Broadway-style entertainment. It’s perfect for those who love a bit more sophistication and adventure.
No matter which one you choose, you’re in for an unforgettable vacation! Which cruise line is your favorite? Let me know in the comments!
